Skip to content

Power curve

The measured power curve of each turbine is compared with two reference curves: its commercial power curve, and its site and period power curve, which accounts for the inflow at the turbine. Each curve is converted into an energy over the same wind: the wind at the turbine during the analysed period.

Typical use: compare a turbine or a fleet with its commercial power curve and with its site and period power curve without a measurement mast, and distinguish an underperforming turbine from a biased nacelle anemometer.

Measured power curve

The measured power curve follows the method of bins of IEC 61400-12-1, on the full-performance records of the period. The wind speed is normalised to the reference air density of the commercial power curve.

The nacelle anemometer sits behind the rotor and does not measure the freestream wind speed. An anemometer that underestimates the wind speed shifts the measured power curve to lower wind speeds and raises the energy deviation. One that overestimates it lowers the deviation. The measured power curve is therefore built twice: on the nacelle wind speed as measured, and on the nacelle wind speed corrected onto the expected hub-height wind speed of the Tipspeed digital twin. The correction removes a calibration bias of the anemometer.

Reference curves

The commercial power curve is the manufacturer's published curve of the turbine model, valid at its reference air density.

The site and period power curve is the expected production of the digital twin, after wakes, binned against the wind speed of the digital twin. It uses the same full-performance records and the same method of bins as the measured power curve. The expected production accounts for the turbulence and the wind shear at the turbine, and for the wakes of its neighbours. It is the production the performance ratio divides by.

The site and period power curve excludes the performance of the turbine itself: its operational power curve and its yaw misalignment. It is the curve a turbine on its commercial power curve would follow on this site over this period. A turbine below its commercial power curve but on its site and period power curve owes its shortfall to its inflow, not to its own performance.

Power of Penmanshiel T12 against the density-corrected nacelle wind speed, with the commercial and the site and period power curves

Power of Penmanshiel T12 in 2019 against the nacelle wind speed, by SCADA status, with the commercial power curve and the site and period power curve (dashed): +2.7% in energy against the commercial power curve, +2.5% against the site and period power curve. Data: Penmanshiel, Cubico, CC-BY-4.0.

Power of Penmanshiel T12 against the corrected nacelle wind speed, with the commercial and the site and period power curves

The same power against the corrected wind speed: 0.0% against the commercial power curve, −0.1% against the site and period power curve. The nacelle anemometer underestimates the wind speed, which adds 2.7 percentage points to the deviation against the commercial power curve. On this site and over this year, the two reference curves are close. Data: Penmanshiel, Cubico, CC-BY-4.0.

Energy deviation

The measured power curve and each reference curve are converted into an energy over the same records: the wind at the turbine during the analysed period. Both energies are computed on the wind speeds that both curves cover.

The deviation is the difference between the energy of the measured power curve and that of the reference curve, in percent of the latter. It is an energy over the analysed period, not an annual energy production (AEP).